Does today's Turkey qualify for a NATO membership? -
Mai 19, 2022
A divergent move by Ankara to block an early vote to begin NATO accession talks for
Sweden and Finland should spark questions about the place of long-
President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan’s Turkey is the only NATO member to object to the Nordic countries’ memberships, the pair wrote, while also being the only country to fail in demonstrating steadfast resolve since Russia’s invasion of Ukraine.
Meanwhile, freedom and transparency in Turkey have suffered under Erdoğan’s almost
All of these developments should spark the question of whether Turkey really belongs in NATO, according to Lieberman and Wallace.
The full article follows below:
Every member of the North Atlantic Treaty Organization has enthusiastically welcomed Finland and Sweden except one: Turkey, which on Wednesday blocked an early vote to begin accession talks. For reasons that are political, parochial and irrelevant to the decision, President Recep Tayyip Erdogan has taken a hard line in his efforts to derail the prospective members. This should raise the question of whether Turkey under Mr. Erdogan’s leadership belongs in the alliance.
Similarly, NATO members have shown steadfast resolve since Vladimir Putin’s invasion of Ukraine, except for Turkey. With the exception of permitting the sale of combat drones to Ukraine—a deal between Kyiv and private defense manufacturer Baykar Makina that was signed before the war—Ankara has offered little more than noisy diplomacy. Mr. Erdogan has tried to position himself as a broker of peace between Ukraine and Russia, mirroring his previous and similarly ineffectual offer to negotiate with the Taliban during America’s withdrawal last year.
This peacemaker’s posture has provided cover for a pattern of cooperation with Moscow,
including Turkey’s purchase of the S-
Mr. Erdogan’s mismanagement of the Turkish economy has left him in need of Russian economic support. While average citizens face soaring costs for basic goods, he continues to dole out gargantuan state contracts to allies, typically through noncompetitive tenders and often for vanity projects. Russia’s support props up Mr. Erdogan’s regime and provides the Turkish president with a kindred antidemocratic ally.
Freedom and transparency in Turkey have suffered under Mr. Erdogan by every measure. The global Corruption Perceptions Index for 2021 ranked Turkey 96th, down from 77th when he became prime minister in 2003. The 2021 Global Democracy Index placed Turkey 103rd, down from 88th in 2006. Finland and Sweden ranked first and fourth, respectively in the 2021 Corruption Perceptions Index, and sixth and fourth in the Global Democracy Index.
Oligarchs close to Mr. Erdogan have systematically acquired Turkish media, while
the government has jailed many opposition journalists, turning a once-
NATO’s greatest strategic failure of the past two decades was to play down Mr. Putin’s malign intent while underestimating its own members’ capacity for collective resolve. The alliance runs the risk of repeating the same mistake with Mr. Erdogan.
Turkey is a member of NATO, but under Mr. Erdogan it no longer subscribes to the values that underpin this great alliance. Article 13 of the NATO charter provides a mechanism for member states to withdraw. Perhaps it is time to amend Article 13 to establish a procedure for the expulsion of a member nation that meets neither the principled nor the practical requirements for membership.
Mr. Lieberman was the Democratic vice-
This article originally appeared in the Wall Street Journal and was reprinted with permision.